Booking Through Thursday – Anything I can do you can do better
Posted on March 22, 2012 in Books
My first Booking Through Thursday in over three years! This is one of my favourite Memes.
Patricia asked:
Ever read a book you thought you could have written better yourself?
My immediate answer is “probably”, but I am not a writer. I have low regard for my ability to do so. I have done creative writing as a teenager, dabbled for fun in it again as a university student, and I even done a couple small shots of fanfiction. That is for fiction, but even for academic papers, I find it difficult to write a lot or with great passion about it. I find it difficult to finish stories I started up, and they say great writers can find stories and characters in themselves and take life. I can find some stories in me, but they don’t want to dragged out or even worse, all my characters seem wholly two dimensional. I compare them always to my favourite books which are often classics or award winning novels.
Though, perhaps I could ghostwrite things if I have the material at hand. An outline, established characters, etc. This really shows how limited I believe my writing capabilities are.
In general, I probably have read a couple of bad books enough to think I have written them better. I just can’t remember these exact titles. I am good at picking out books which I generally like and usually, I can’t even think about writing something better. It’s not something that really comes into my head when I read a book that is mediocre or worse. I just rather think I hadn’t read it at all.
I’ve come across books that I feel I could do a better job editing in my years. And there are a few stories I think I could take the same elements and come up with a better story. But the authors in question have done what I haven’t–got their work completed and published.
Hi Michael. I agree that there have been a few books that I think could be better edited as well. As well, I agree that some stories could be improved on. But like you say, the authors were able to get the work done and published, not a very easy business.
My answer is so much shorter than most today!
Here’s My BTT
I don’t think that I could have written it better, but if I was the editor I’d have demanded at least one rewrite.
Not rewrite, but I think I could have been a better editor than some of those books had.